American Totalitarianism versus Soviet Repression Hannah Arendt

American Totalitarianism: Never have we depended so much on political forces that cannot be trusted


As we watch how intolerance, repression of diversity and totalitarianism is growing yet again in the West, the German philosopher, Hannah Arendt is worth revisiting.

She is considered one of the most influential political theorists of the 20th century and spent many years examining how it was possible for a modern, democratic state such as pre-World War II Germany, to turn into a totalitarian state and a brutal regime that killed millions of its own population.

“Never has our future been more unpredictable, never have we depended so much on political forces that cannot be trusted to follow the rules of common sense and self-interest—forces that look like sheer insanity, if judged by the standards of other centuries.” ― Hannah Arendt, The Origins of Totalitarianism.

In The Origins of Totalitarianism, she analyzed the 20th century growth of totalitarianism that led to the silencing of an entire population out of fear for their own, ruling elites, writes Hanne Nabintu Herland, historian of comparative religions and columnist in the United States’ largest Conservative network at World Net Daily.

WND is America’s largest Conservative network with columnists such as Larry Elder, Ann Coulter, John Whitehead, Joseph Farah, Ben Shapiro, Dinesh d’Souza, Pat Buchanan, Dennis Prager, David Kupelian, Jesse Lee Peterson and most of the famous Conservatives in the United States.


American Totalitarianism: New Left Tyranny, by bestselling author Hanne Nabintu Herland
American Totalitarianism: New Left Tyranny author, bestselling Scandinavian author, Hanne Herland is a regular contributor to the leading Conservative outlets in the United States. The book is available on USA Amazon, UK Amazon here . «This is a remarkable book by a remarkable person. Excellent work.” Dr. Paul Craig Roberts, leading American political economist


American Totalitarianism: And it was precisely in Marxist-infused nations, such as the leftwing National Socialist (NAZI) system under Hitler and Communism under Stalin that the rigid requirement of consensus, both ethnically, socially and religiously, took place.

The socialist group-think, strict requirement of consensus, repression of free speech, zero tolerance for diversity of opinion, harsh consequences for those who did not confirm to the standards of the government, a unison media narrative describing what to think and feel in every subject – this combined with strict ruling elites that controlled the economy made totalitarianism possible.




With it came the concentration camps and the Gulag, which Nobel Prize laureate, Alexandr Solzhenitsyn pointed out is an inevitable consequence of communism – one of the fruits of Marxism: The need to get physically rid of those who oppose the system since these are considered the obstacle to total unity and “the communist paradise”.

Solzhenitsyn came to understand that Marxism and its offspring communism was wrong in asserting that fight for justice was that between the proletariat – the working class – and the capitalist class.

He explains in The Gulag Archipelago: “Gradually, it was disclosed to me that the line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties – but right through every human heart – and then through all human hearts…And even within hearts overwhelmed by evil, one small bridgehead of good is retained. And even in the best of all hearts, there remains…an un-uprooted small corner of evil.”

Centerfold in Karl Marx’ and Friedrich Engels’ work The Communist Manifesto from 1848, is the idea that the only solution to injustice between the classes is bloody revolution and terror.

Only in this way, the working class would take power, expropriate funds and confiscate private property from the former ruling class and spend them in a new, socialist system.

“There is only one way to shorten and ease the convulsions of the old society and the bloody birth pangs of the new – revolutionary terror,” Marx argued.

American Totalitarianism: Yet Marx, rather introduced a system where a Marxist government elite would replace the existing elites, controlling the communist working class even more than before. The repression seen among the horrifyingly intolerant communist state lords, where millions were sent to concentration camps and millions killed by their own leaders, defined totalitarian terror in the 20th century.

It is socialism – also a fruit of Marxism – that over time alters the population from being independent thinkers with individual rights protected by a conservative Constitution to becoming subordinate, group-think indoctrinated communities full of fear for the government.

The change within the population goes from actively participating in local governments, speaking their minds, always looking for the abuse of power and addressing these topics in the media – to becoming a silent group in which ‘everyone publicly has the same opinion,’ completely in line by one-sided media propaganda that only tells the government narrative.

In such a system, the people becomes the tyranny of the mob, effectively turning each other over to the Gestapo in a system of active informants reporting and surveilling one another, in accordance with the will of the media owning elites.

Many who escaped the Soviet Union later told their stories. Yuri Mashkov was one of them, a Soviet dissident who was exiled to the United States in the 1970s. He explained at a conference in New Jersey in 1978 that his life, in which he had spent many years in the Soviet concentration camps, came to change once he realized the reality behind the Soviet propaganda, that the system was completely repressive without justice or any kind of freedom.

His training had taught him that Communism was an idealistic teaching that brought happiness and peace. Mashkov describes the horror when realizing that in reality, Communism was the very opposite.

He discovered that Marxism in essence was a complete teaching of totalitarianism, of an absolute slavery, of the state desire for full control over its citizens.


About the author

The level of censorship in social media and search engines is all-time high. Do like thousands of others, subscribe to The Herland Report newsletter here!

Hanne Nabintu Herland is a historian of religions and bestselling author. She is the founder of The Herland Report Scandinavian news site, TV channel on YouTube and Podcasts which have millions of readers/viewers. This is a great place to watch interviews with leading intellectuals, thought leaders from across the political spectrum. Herland’s books include Alarm, Respect, Det Nye Babylon (2018), Tyranni (2020) and in English – The Culture War. How the West lost its Greatness (2017)Trump. The Battle for America (2020) as well as  New Left Tyranny. The Authoritarian Destruction of Our Way of Life (2020), available on Amazon, Barnes and Noble, across the USA and in 60 countries world-wide. New Left Tyranny shows how the neo-Marxist New Left turned their back on historical Western principles and became a destructive authoritarian force.

Herland Report Newsletter Subscribe

Check Also

Democrats have openly been calling for a Final Solution on Trump problem FOX

Democrats have openly been calling for a Final Solution on Trump problem

  It became cliché that Donald Trump was the embodiment of all evil and needed …

Donald Trump shooting: The closest we've come to WWIII Downplaying the assassination attempt on Donald Trump: FOX.

Instantly downplaying the assassination attempt on Donald Trump: How the despicable Mainstream Media constantly twists the truth

  No doubt there will be a lot of speculation about the assassination attempt of …

Book The Billionaire World Hanne Nabintu Herland How Marxism Serves the Elite